Entertainment

Weighing-In On Miley Cyrus Photo Flap

Name : Charlene
Hometown : Limerick
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : inappropriate for a 15 year old no matter what the circumstance.

Name : MK
Hometown : Philadelphia
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think that pic of her really doesn't even look good..it kind of looks like a picture of a corps?!?!--Am I the only one who thinks that? I think people should live their lives how they want to live it, but when you are a celebrity, you should know that whatever you do will make it to the public eye--ESPECIALLY something like this. She should have thought about the outcomes of the pictures before she went in front of the camera instead of waiting until the picteres were out to apologize. She is only 15, and I know that age can have its difficult moments when trying to pre-judge actions, but her parents DEFINITELY should have seen this coming. I feel bad for her because she is so young and her parents obviously don't care about all the bad media coming out of this. My nieces love her and they are only 6 and 7!?!--I don't think those pics are appropriate for children that age, so you do have to think about your fan base when taking action like this. It's probably just a PR stunt to get her in the lime light even more than she already was?!?!

Name : Hannah
Hometown : Nashville
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think the picture is fine. i dont know why there is so much drama and talk about the photos. and now her show might not even air anymore. all because SOME people think its inappropriate. She is 15 for heavensake. Stop putting SO MUCH pressure on this girl. if you dont agree that the picture is fine, then your just jealous of her. and thats too Bad! Miley, keep living up your dream. Love always, Hannah

Name : Rachael
Hometown : Phoenixville
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : The photo would have been artsy if the poser was 18 years old. She's not a legal adult, she was clearly not wearing a shirt. For someone of her age, it was inappropriate for the photographer to take those for an international website. I'm fifteen years old as well, and I might have done the same thing if I was Miley, but they would not have ended up in public. I think she's trying to live like every other teenage girl, but she needs to realize that she is not every other teenage girl- she's a superstar with a very young fan base. I don't think Miley should have to apologize for these photos, but they were more inappropriate than artsy.

Name : Tony
Hometown : Newark
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : What kid reads Vanity Fair?It's only a big issue because the media makes it a big issue.Now every kid in America will see or know about the photographs and think its wrong instead of art.If parents don't like it,then maybe they should try to be someone their kids can look up too!

Name : Barbara
Hometown : Bear,De.
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : Inappropriate,and the people that agree to things like this are the reasons why we keep edging our way toward bigger and worse things then suddenly we look back and see how far over the limit we've really gone but then we just keep going anyway.

Name : Elissa
Hometown : Folsom
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I loved Billy Raye when I was a child but I was shocked and appalled that he allowed his 15 year old daughter take those pictures! I myself am 23 and would never be caught dead taking pictures like that especially with my father! Billy Raye should be ashamed!

Name : Allison
Hometown : Pennsylvania
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think this photo is inappropriate. But she apoligized and thats what matters. I will still watch her shows. I still look up to her even know she made a mistake. She is still my favorite Disney singer and actor.

Name : Hannah
Hometown : Dover
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think the photo is very inapropiate. Why would she choose to pose for these so called artists and then apologize.It was her choice theres no changing it. Miley's idea is in the past now.

Name : Maia
Hometown : Pennslyvania
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : Before I hated Miley because I thought she was cheesy and stupid. In this photo she looks like a beautiful model and that is something I admire.

Name : Lynne
Hometown : Phillipsburg NJ
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : inappropriate to be viewed by the public

Name : Lois
Hometown : New Castle, De
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think it's artsy. Miley, like all child stars, is becoming a young woman, and the public is shocked by the realization. It shows no more "flesh" or provacativity than many "bath soap" commericals to which our children are exposed to on a daily basics..except it Miley.

Name : Jina
Hometown : coatesville, pa
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : As an serious amateur photographer, this may be some of Annie L.'s best work. As she certainly has achieved the look and feel of an dutch oil painting. However it is wholly inappropriate for anybody under the age of 21 period. If I were a parent my children would be supporters of those with real talent and not those manufactured by mega corporations with no concern or not if they are selling children snake oil from jump. My personal opinion on Cyrus is her talents have fallen very far from her father's tree. I don't watch or support her efforts, nor would I allow if I had children to do the same. The ones I'm close to are thankfully not among the cult of Hanna Montana. As to the whole photo shot blame can be laid around all around, especially with the so called adults who should have had the final say over what got taken, what got used and what finally made to print. The apology is shallow now.

Name : Maria
Hometown : Montgomery Township, PA
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : She is 15 years old after all. A minor. Inappropriate in my opinion. I know people say you see this on the beach with teens in bikinis etc, but it's expected there. That is a natural environment for bikinis. Miley's situation is deliberate and calculated. Miley has a "come hither" look and it is a seductive pose with her being topless. I think she and her family were pressured to get even more celebrity and caved-in to the pressure of stardom. It's a shame. I would not let my 15 year old pose like this for a photo. Annie L. could have chosen to do a nice artsy shot that was more age-appropriate.

Name : Marie
Hometown : Florida
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think the photo was artsy because everyone is making a big deal out of nothing. Its just photos she said she was sorry so they should just get over it and she made a mistake. She is teenager that is only 15 and she is going to make mistakes like that and everyone makes mistakes. I mean i just don't get why all of her fans are mad at her she said she was sorry. What i think is that everyone should just stop talking about it and leave that girl alone your putting a lot of pressure on her and i also think that is not a big deal and people need to get over It.

Name : Doris
Hometown : Stroudsburg
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think the pictures are not exploiting at all. If she wanted to pose that way, so be it. I have seen much worse.

Name : melanie
Hometown : chester county, pa
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think the photo was her and her family's choice. Who are we to judge?? My daughter who is 7, just loves her. I am not going to stop her from watching her show!! People forget that she is a celebrity and that she is growing up. She has nothing to apoligize for. Just remember she is a teenager. Everything she does will be put in the spotlight!! Just imagine if other teens out there had every picture of them with friends and every move the make in the public eye. No one would look perfect. I do not see any problems with the pictures that the magazine took.

Name : Mom
Hometown : Maple Shade
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : Annie's photos are beautiful, but, Miley should have said "no,I'm only 14". Mom and Dad should have said no FIRST.

Name : Kathryn Holmes
Hometown : Delran
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I honestly believe Miley's parents lost what sense they had. They were present for the photo shoot and allowed their 15 year old child to pose in such a manner. They are way more concerned with making money than with guiding their daughter down the correct path.

Name : Erica
Hometown :
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I checked out the pics she is a beautiful girl the pics of her are wonderful with herself and the ones with her father but why do these young girl think they have to take their cloths off to look good for poto shots?

Name : embarresed
Hometown : philly
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : i have a 11 year old girl.......this country should be be emarrased over this...i would never ever want the ......MONEY........OR ....FAME.........to have my daughter exposed like that...MONEY.....GREEEEEED...MONEY.......AND ......GREED....this is a sad day in my life...what ever happened to our morals...????????

Name : Tina
Hometown : McGuire AFB, NJ
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I don't think the photo is all that bad and usually she is a sensible girl who has good parents. I think people should just chalk it up to a session that wasn't what she thought it would be and leave her alone. All this fuss is just stupid to me.

Name : Lance
Hometown : Ephrata, PA
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I can't understand the big flap. With teens and preteens sending pics, nude and non nude, with their cell phones, those pics are tame. Seems like most of the people that are complaining, have spent the last 20n years in a cave on Mars.

Name : Brooke
Hometown : Philadelphia
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I think it's a shame she would put herself out there like that it's very inappropriate.

Name : John
Hometown : Philadelphia
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : It was artsy she has nothing to be embarrassed about.

Name : Leonard
Hometown : Newark, De
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : It is stupid that her dad would let this happen in the first place. As a parent myself, I would not let my daughter make such pictures, let alone pose like that with her! They posed like they were a couple and not father and daughter. It is his responsibility to protect her and not exploit her!

Name : Jazzy
Hometown : Vineland, NJ
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : I don't think the photos were inappropriate at all. To me, it does look artsy. Shame on those who has a sick mentality. She seems like she's going to be a lot smarter than other young celebs. This is something small that people can exaggerate on just to make money.

Name : Pete Smith
Hometown : Leola, Pa
What do you think about the photo? Was it artsy or inappropriate? : If I had taken a picture like that of a 15 year old girl an posted it on the internet then I would have been arrested as a sexual predator!

(© MMVIII, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.)